Andy Gray is an idiot, but Murdoch is much worse

Those with too much power are becoming extremely clever at using liberal values to scapegoat their enemies.

First Julian Assange, and now Andy Gray. Two individuals brave enough (whatever you think of them, and I personally think they’re both morons, they are brave) to stand up to some of the world’s most powerful governments and News International respectively, both discredited in the name of feminism.

Naomi Wolfe wrote a furious piece in the Huffington Post about Julian Assange’s charges, and why we shouldn’t trust the accusations of rape, the logic being that rape is not usually treated this way. I would very much like to see an article comparing Sky Sports’ dropping of Andy Gray to other dealings with sexism in the Murdoch media. How do reporters usually talk about women when they’re off-air (believing themselves, with as much naivety as Gordon Brown when he accidentally called Gillian Duffy a bigot, to be in private)? Are these comments really unheard of in the workplace?

Obviously Sky Sports, and the rest of media, judging by their condemnation of Gray, are much more enlightened than most of the places I’ve worked, because ‘banter’ like this doesn’t surprise me. Don’t get me wrong, it infuriates me. It’s just fairly commonplace.

So the question isn’t whether we like Andy Gray, or want him to stay in the job. The question is, as with Julian Assange, is he being singled out and treated differently from any other employees? Employees who perhaps hadn’t tried to take legal action against News International?

Judging by the number of people who think his remarks were spot on (equally infuriating, by the way), I have to imagine that yes, he is.

Let’s ask ourselves this. If a left-wing News International employee who had brought charges against News International for phone-hacking made a controversial comment off-air, perhaps of the bigot-gate variety, and they were sacked, without consultation or warning, would we really be celebrating?

I am disgusted by the comments he made. I think he’s an idiot and I don’t, on any personal level, feel sympathy for Andy Gray or give a damn that he’s gone. But underneath it, there’s a much more alarming message to us all: don’t mess with Murdoch.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Andy Gray is an idiot, but Murdoch is much worse

Add yours

  1. Andy Gray Lou.

    You can’t call a professional’s competence into question SOLELY on the basis of gender and expect not to be in trouble, particularly when you’re employed as an expert in that field. If done at a job interview, it would be illegal – correctly.

    There are open mics everywhere in studios and he knew it. If he’d cultivated more friends, he might have ridden it out, but everyone knows he’s an arse and had it coming to him.

    The Murdoch angle is a red herring – he’d have been gone even quicker from the BBC.

  2. “Let’s ask ourselves this. If a left-wing News International employee who had brought charges against News International for phone-hacking made a controversial comment off-air, perhaps of the bigot-gate variety, and they were sacked, without consultation or warning, would we really be celebrating?”

    Probably. A lot of bigots are very careful to say the right thing on camera, and never get found out. I do feel sympathy for Gray and Keys – they’ve lost, irretrievably, the job they loved – but they were a part, however small, of a very large cultural guano which nourishes several brands of archaic nonsense, such as misogyny.

    If a Left-Wing employee was caught claiming that women didn’t understand the offside rule, insinuating that they just weren’t as clever or able as men, then I’d be happy to see them go. Plenty of Left-Wing people out there riddled with class prejudice and all sorts of things.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: